Non implementation of family pension rules BPS writes to JS DOP&PW with a representative list of long pending family pension cases.
No BPS/SG/ Dated 15/09/021
To
The Joint Secretary,
GOI Ministry of Personnel,PG & Pensions -DOP&PW
(For the personal attention of Sh. S.N. Mathur )
Subject: Implementation of family pension rules
Sir,
Bharat
Pensioners Samaj on behalf of its members & affiliates is thankful to DOP &PW for the family pension rules
awareness campaign for elderly. Through video conference, publication of
compendiums & through the Social media.
However,
Sir, of what use is all this effort if the family pension rules are not
implemented at ground level. Reality in this respect is far from satisfactory.
So much so there are cases where it takes years & years & even decades
for widows, widowed/unmarried dependent daughters & divorced daughters.
For
example we invite your attention to the painful case of widow Ms Kanchan Goala
which took 23yrs to get her final settlement & family pension. We are thankful to Shri Harjit Singh then Director (PP) who
helped us to take the case to its logical end after 23yrs from the death in
harness of her husband (Ref :BPS/SG/DOPPW/018/4 dated 08.07.2018 addressed to )
Shri Harjit Singh)
Sir,
even today quite a number of eligible
unmarried dependent/widowed/divorced daughters of late pensioners are
waiting for years for the sanction of family pension due to the indifferent
attitude of officers/officials in different Ministries & Departments who do
not respect the rules framed by DOP&PW. Especially, in the Ministry of
Railways/PCDA and DOT/BSNL. We are attaching herewith a representative list of
such pending cases with the hope that the Department headed by you will live up to the purpose it
has been constituted & come to the aid to these helpless eligible
candidates for family pension who are being harassed & exploited in
different ways by the concerned staff.
Thanking you
With regards DA/As
above
Yours faithfully,
S.c.Maheshwari
Secretary General Bharat
Pensioners Samaj
Statement
Showing
long pending( since August 2013) case of family pension-DOT/BSNL as on
15.09.2021
|
Name
|
Date
of claim submitted |
Sanctioning
Authority. |
Reason
for Pendency |
Remarks |
|
Smt.
Varsha M. Patel Widow daughter of late Shri Manubhai Shakarabhai Patel, Staff
No. 6294 was serving in the A.T.D. Ahmedabad as Telephone Supervisor. He
retired on superannuation on 01.04.1990. Shri
Manubhai Shakarabhai Patel, father of Smt. Varshaben M Patel (widowed
Daughter), expired on 07.08.2013 at Ahmedabad. |
Her
father had applied for considering her for family pension as his wife was
expired and he was supporting widow daughter. Family Pension Case
pending since Agust. 2013. She submitted her claim after the deathof his
father who had included her as dependent in his family declaration while in
sevice
|
The
C.C.A. Gujarat
Telecom Circle, Ahmedabad-380001. |
Self
declaration of income not accepted .Then She submitted Affidavit Signed by
Magistrate declaring that her income is Nil. She also submitted income certificate from Ahmedabad
Municipal Comparator showing her income as NIL. She
has replied to all queries and got documents countersigned by competent
Authority wherever required. |
The
Govt. of Gujarat has issued GR to all Collectors not to issue Income
Certificate to any person having income less than Rs1,50,000/. As such
revenue authorities are not issuing income certificate to persons having
income less than Rs 1,50000/
|
Statement showing representative list
of long pending cases of family pension over NF Railway ason 15.09.021
Details of Cases
|
S/N |
Deptt |
Name & Designation |
PPO NO with Date |
Grievances |
Present Status |
|
1 |
MED |
Miss Sangita Basfore u/m daughter of
Late Sudai Basfore ex. S/Cleaner under MS/NJP |
1608020680 dt.31-07-2002 |
Life time children Pension |
Lying at the office of ADFM/NJP,
second time after compliance of all observations. |
|
2 |
MED |
Smt. Jaya Sekhar, divorced daughter
of Late K. Chandrasekhar ex. Hd.Clerk/CMS/NJP |
NJP/PN/997 dt.30-06-1995 |
-do- |
-do- |
|
3 |
Mech. |
Smt. Manabi Guha, widow daughter of
Late Satya Ranjan Sarkar, ex.Fitter/HS/I/SGUJ |
KIR/PN/2028 dt.12-07-2011 |
-do- |
Lying at the office of DRM/P/KIR |
|
4 |
Mech. |
Smt. Tandra Poddar, widow daughter
of Late Gagan Ch. Sarkar, |
KIR/PN/9865 dt.30-04-1995 |
-do- |
-do- |
|
5 |
Tfc. |
Smt. Nibedita Ray Sarkar, widow
daughter of Late Amal Kr. Ray ex.CCC/II/NJP under Sr.DCM/KIR |
0204970209 dt,28-02-1997 |
-do- |
-do- |
|
6 |
Mech. |
Miss Kalyani Chakraborty, unmarried
daughter of Late Manmatha Nath Chakraborty, ex.OS/KIR under Sr.DME/KIR |
KIR/PN/5391 dt.03-10-1999 |
-do- |
At the office of Sr.DFM/KIR |
|
7 |
Engg. |
Smt. Urmila Devi, widow daughter of
Late Balindra Bhagat, ex. G.Mate/KIR under Sr.DEN/KIR |
0206961881 dt.31-12-1996 |
-do- |
-do- |
|
8 |
Tfc. |
Smt. Gita Majumdar Dhar, widow
daughter of Late Hari Prasad Majumdar, ex.AYM/NJP under Sr.DOM/KIR |
KIR/PN/2966 dt.30-06-1983 |
-do- |
-do- |
|
9 |
Mech. |
Smt. Banani Saha, divorced daughter of late Brojendranath Saha, ex.
Driver(ME)/KIR under Sr.DME/KIR |
0207990438 dt.31-05-1999 |
-do- |
-do- |
(Page-2)
|
S/N |
Deptt |
Name & Designation |
PPO NO with Date |
Grievances |
Present Status |
|
10 |
Mech. |
Smt. Jayati Sengupta, divorced
daughter of Late Himangshu Sengupta, ex. Progress Man/G/I/NJP under
Sr.DME/KIR |
0207030066 dt.31-01-2003 |
Life time children Pension |
At the office of Sr.DFM/KIR |
|
11 |
Mech. |
Miss Rekha Das, u/m daughter of Late
Mano Mohan Das, ex.Driverr/G/NJP under Sr.DME/KIR |
KIR/PN/2381 dt.30-01-1982 |
Life time children pension. OLD
CASE SUBMITTED ON 13-02-2012
|
Lying at the office of DRM/P/KIR |
|
12 |
Engg. |
Sri Sankar Bhattacharjee, Mentally
Retarded son of Late Jagadish Ch. Bhattacharjee, ex. IOW/NJP (under
guardianship of Sri Bhaskar Bhattacharjee) |
Rly./8074 of July/1972 |
Life time children pension 1st date of submission –
12-05-2011, latest submission after compliance on 17-03-2021 & 13-05-2021 |
-do- |
|
13 |
Elect. |
Smt. Bela Ghosh, wife of Late Robin
Ghosh, ex.Sr.Meter Reader/KIR |
KIR/PN/7011 dt. 09-09-2020 (Postal) |
7th CPC Revised PPO |
Lying at the office of DRM/P/KIR |
|
14 |
Mech. |
Sri Sushanta Kumar Sarkar, ex.Loco
Pilot/NJP now deceased |
2007050200495 dt.03-12-2018 |
Mistake in Surname – to be Sarkar
instead of wrongly shown as Sakar |
-do- |
|
15 |
Tfc. |
Sri Dhruba Lal Banerjee, ex.
Guard/Mail/Express/NJP |
20047050200657 dt.12-01-2001 |
Designation wrongly shown as Guards
Goods instead of Mail/Express. Required re-issue of Revised PPO with
necessary correction. |
-do- (Corrigendum as sent does not
generate UMID Card) |
|
16 |
Engg. |
Smt. Sita Bala Roy, wife of late
Guman Ch., Roy,ex.Mate/NJP |
19967050200535 dt.24-12-2018 |
Error in the name of wife, shown as
ZITA instead of SITA. |
-do- Fresh revised PPO is to be
issued with correction in name of wife. |
|
17 |
Elect. |
Smt. Geeta Roy, widow of Late
Ranajit Kumar Roy, ex. Hd. Meter Reader/SGUJ |
0205030294 dt. |
Non receipt of 7th CPC
revised PPO( A wrong number shown as 20047050200046 belong to Shiv Narayan
Sinha) |
Lying at the office of DRM/P/KIR |
|
18 |
PERS |
Smt. Saraswati Roy, wife of Late Chitta
Ranjan Roy, ex.Goods Clerk/SGUT |
KIR/PN/7234 |
A wrong revised PPO
No.19907050200119 in the name of one Aparna Chakraborty was sent) |
Sr.DFM/KIR |
(Page-3)
|
S/N |
Deptt |
Name & Designation |
PPO NO with Date |
Grievances |
Present Status |
|
19 |
Mech. |
Smt. Lipika Goswami, wife of Late
Tapas Kumar Goswami, ex.C/Khalasi/NJP |
19977050200365 dt.19-11-2017 |
Error in the 7th CPC
revised PPO (1) Surname – written as GOSW instead of GOSWAMI (2) Date of
birth of wife written as 04-12-1968 instead of 04-12-1966 as recorded in
initial PPO etc. A fresh revised PPO is to be issued. |
Sr.DPO/KIR |
|
20 |
Tfc. |
Smt. Sandhya Samddar, wife of Late
H. K. Samaddar, ex. CTRC/NJP |
KIR/PEN/1349 |
7th CPC revised PPO not received |
DRM/P/KIR |
|
21 |
Engg. |
Smt. Kanchan Goala, wife of Late
Rathindra Nath Goala, ex. Khalasi Helper/CIOW/NJP |
KIR/PN/10217 (A) |
Non receipt of sanctioned PPO,
getting Pension. |
Sr.DFM/KIR |
|
22 |
Mech. |
Sri Dulal Ch. Ganguly, Driver
Mail/Exp. NJP |
20057050200654 dt.31-10-2019 |
Fresh issue of 7th CPC
revised PPO including the name of legally married second wife after death of
first wife. All documents submitted and enquiry done. |
DRM/P/KIR |
|
23 |
Mech. |
Sri Lalan Kr. Singh, Tech./I/NJP
under SSE/IC/C&W/NJP |
20137050200416 dt.10-10-2017 |
Revised PPO, said sent, but not yet
received |
Sr.DFM/KIR |
|
24 |
Tfc. |
Smt. Reba Chakraborty, wife of Late
Khagendra Nath Chakraborty, ex.Guard/M/NJP |
KIR/PN/7179 dt.03-05-2019 (through
Post Office) |
Error in the date of birth of 7th
CPC revised PPO shown as 02-04-1940 to be 20-04-1940 (a fresh PPO is to be
issued) |
-do- |
|
25 |
Engg. |
Smt. Binodini Ray, wife of Late
Sushil Singha Ray, ex. Gangman/SSE/P.Way/NJP |
KIR/PN/7675 dt.Feb/2000 |
7th CPC Revised PPO |
-do- |
|
26 |
Stores /NJP |
Smt. Sikha Ray, wife of Late Kartick
Kr. Roy, ex. Hd.Clerk/DCOS/NJP |
NJP/PN/555 dt.01-02-1990 |
7th CPC Revised PPO |
ADFM/NJP |
|
27 |
Mech |
Smt. Swapna Mazumdar, wife of Late
Ajoy Kr. Mazumdar. Ex. LP/NJP |
KIR/PN/8998 dt.31-01-1994 |
7th CPC Revised PPO |
Sr.DFM/KIR |
|
28 |
Mech |
Smt. Gouri Das, wife of Late
Manindra Nath Das, ex.HC/SSE/Loco/NJP |
0207021934 dt.31-07-2002 |
7th CPC Revised PPO |
-do- |
|
29 |
Mech. |
Sri Sibasray Choubey, ex.
Driver/G/NJP |
0207030099 dt.19-12-2003 |
7th CPC Revised PPO |
Sr.DFM/KIR |
Page 4
|
S/N |
Deptt |
Name & Designation |
PPO NO with Date |
Grievances |
Present Status |
|
30 |
Mech. |
Smt. Jyoti Rupa Munshi, wife of Late
Saroj Kumar Munshi, ex.Driver/P/NJP |
KIR/PN/6166 dt.31-01-1989 |
7th CPC/Revised PPO |
Sr.DFM/KIR |
Comments